Goodbye to the Stress Test for Uninsured Switches

In as many weeks, Canadians got another big announcement when it came to mortgages last week, and it may lead some to think, what's next? After the federal government announced surprise changes to amortization and maximum purchase prices for insured mortgages a couple weeks ago, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions seemed to have a hold my beer moment and made a huge surprise announcement themselves, this one was around uninsured, or conventional, mortgages.

First, who is the Office of the Supervisor of Financial Institutions, or OSFI for short? OSFI is an independent agency of the government of Canada that regulates and supervises financial institutions, in order to contribute public confidence in the financial system. Being independent, even though they are a part of the federal government, they are able to set their mandates and make decisions independently of government intervention.

Last week, OSFI announced that effective November 21st, they would scrap the requirement for financial institutions to stress test clients when the clients are looking to switch their uninsured mortgage from one lender to another. This is a huge win for mortgage holders as it now makes it easier to obtain the most competitive mortgage rates and products when your mortgage comes up for renewal, even if they are not with your current lender.

Currently, if someone wanted to switch their mortgage to a new lender, they would have to prove that they could afford the mortgage at a higher rate, also known as the stress test, which qualifies the mortgage at 5.25% or the contract rate + 2%, whichever is higher. The issue here is that by having the stress test in place, it could effectively block you from switching a mortgage that you are already affording to a new lender because the stress test may say you actually can't afford it.

This potential roadblock could possibly lead to your lender offering higher rates because they may think, or know, that you have nowhere else to go and will have no choice but to renew with them at whichever rate they offer. It is important to note that OSFI has said that it has found no evidence of this happening; however, the potential does present an unfair advantage to your current lender.

This potential unfairness was the subject of a Competition Bureau recommendation to OSFI this past March that was actually turned down by OSFI where they announced that they had no plans to remove the stress test on uninsured mortgages when a client was looking to switch lenders. As part of its recommendation, the Competition Bureau criticized the rule and said that switching lenders and promoting fairness should be focused on more than discouraging the practice.

Six short months later, OSFI makes a complete 180 and will now allow the increased competition. As mentioned this is a huge win for mortgage holders, especially ahead of the next few years, which are set to have the most mortgages coming up for renewal.

To summarize the change, when your uninsured mortgage comes up for renewal and your lenders offers you renewal options, you can now shop your mortgage with a Mortgage Broker to see which lenders would offer competitive interest rates and products that would allow you to switch your mortgage to them by qualifying at the actual contract rate, not the higher rate. You do still need to qualify to prove that you can afford the mortgage; however, you don't need to qualify at an inflated rate presented by having to use the stress test. This may even lead to your current lender offering more attractive renewal rates since they know there will no longer be the obstacle that could stop you from reviewing other options.

Overall, this is an announcement that has been advocated for by the mortgage industry for a long time and ensures fairness to Canadian mortgage borrowers. It has been a big couple of weeks with a few surprise announcements to rules and regulations that Mortgage Brokers have been pushing for and up to now thought that there would be no movement by the regulators in charge of them.