Episode # 34 of the Mortgage Foundations Podcast
A common term and form of advertising to hear in the mortgage industry is that "in most cases, my services are free". While it may come across that Mortgage Brokers are doing the work for nothing, in reality, it really comes down to who pays us, and more often, it is the lender, not the borrower.
For a typical, well qualified mortgage file that is done on the Prime, or A lending side, a Mortgage Broker is paid by the lender as a form of commission, or finder's fee. I will discuss broker fees shortly; however, it is important to note that most Prime lenders do not allow Mortgage Brokers to charge any fees, such as a broker fee, to the client. If you are having a mortgage done by a Broker where a broker fee is being charged, and it is with a Prime lender, it is recommended to discuss this with the broker and lender to ensure everything is being done properly.
A finder's fee is paid to the Mortgage Broker by the lender after the mortgage has funded, also known as the closing day, and is generally a percentage of the mortgage amount. A typical percentage is one percentage of the funded amount; however, it varies amongst lenders and is higher or lower depending on the length of the term.
On top of the finder's fee, a Mortgage Broker may also receive other incentives, such as Volume Bonuses from lenders that a Mortgage Broker uses commonly or Efficiency Bonuses from lenders to award Mortgage Brokers that send quality files or promotions that are offered by lenders from time to time.
Another form of commission that a Mortgage Broker may make from a lender are trailer fees. A trailer fee is a form of commission that is paid over time rather than all up front. A finder's fee is still paid shortly after closing the mortgage; however, it is smaller than normal since a portion of it is paid out annually. This method of getting paid is preferred by some brokers as it stretches out their income stream and may allow better control of funds.
When a Mortgage Broker works on a file that is suitable for an alternative, also known as a B lender, or a private lender, they may charge a broker fee, which is a fee for their services that is paid for by the client and is normally processed on closing day and collected by the client's lawyer and then sent to the Mortgage Broker.
The reason that a broker fee may be charged on these types of files is that some of these lenders do not pay a finder's fee to the Mortgage Broker directly; or they offer a lower finder's fee than normal.
It is important to note that a broker fee may not be charged on alternative files since the lender may offer a suitable finder's fee to compensate the Mortgage Broker. If a broker fee is being charged, it could be that the lender does not pay a finder's fee or there was a substantial amount of work put into the file, or a combination of both. Most private mortgages will feature a broker fee as the majority of private lenders do not pay the Mortgage Broker any compensation.
Whether a mortgage is being done with a prime, alternative, or private lender, a Mortgage Broker should always be transparent about their method of compensation and be open to explaining who is paying them for their services, the lender, the client, or both? A Mortgage Broker is also required to disclose how they get paid directly to the client on the Disclosure To Borrower document that is given to the client during the mortgage process. If your Mortgage Broker is not transparent or has not disclosed this information to you, it is recommended to ask why and get more information to ensure you are protected.
There is nothing wrong with asking your Mortgage Broker if there is a different product available to you that would pay the Mortgage Broker less money in order to save you more money over the course of your mortgage. In fact, Mortgage Brokers are regulated to ensure that the mortgage product offered to the client is in the best interest of the client, and recommendations were made without weighing the broker's compensation above the client's interests.
It is also important to note that a Mortgage Broker is not paid directly by the client, and all compensation must go through the mortgage brokerage that the Broker represents, no matter what type of compensation it is. If your Mortgage Broker or Agent is requesting payment directly, you should discuss this with the Principal Broker of the brokerage or the regulator, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario.
In conclusion, a Mortgage Broker does not really work for free; however, our services may be free to you, the client, since they are paid for by the lender as a finder's fee or other type of lender compensation. A broker fee may be charged on files that are done with an alternative lender or a private lender. All compensation earned by a Mortgage Broker or Agent is to be paid through their mortgage brokerage and is never paid directly to the Broker or Agent. Lastly, a Mortgage Broker is regulated to not put their commission ahead of your best interests and must be transparent and disclose how they get paid and how pays them, if your Mortgage Broker is not, you should question why!